Bertrand Russell on the Budda’s and the Christian’s Ideal, and Nietzsche’s ‘Pathology’

By | October 16, 2012

Juan Bernal

In his book, A History of Western Philosophy,*  Bertrand Russell makes some rather surprising statements about love as definitive of two great religions, Christianity and Buddhism.   It is in the process of contrasting what he sees as advocacy of love by Christianity and the Buddha with what he takes as Friedrich Nietzsche’s ethic, that Russell contrasts the Christianity’s and Buddhists love for humanity with Nietzsche’s complete lack of sympathy for others. In the process Russell effectively misleads us both with regard to the religious ideal and Nietzsche’s philosophy.

Near the end of his section on Nietzsche (** pp. 760-773), Russell takes up what he calls the “ethical, as opposed to the political question.”

“The ethical, as opposed to the political, question is one as to sympathy. Sympathy, in the sense of being made unhappy by the suffering of others, is to some extent natural to human beings; … But the development of this feeling is very different in different people. Some find pleasure in the infliction of torture; others, like Buddha, feel that they cannot be completely happy so long as any living thing is suffering.” (p. 771)

Since he will eventually contrast Buddha’s ethics with Nietzsche’s, Russell here insinuates that the Buddha sought happiness, which he could not realize as long as others were suffering; whereas others –Does he mean to include Nietzsche here? -  find pleasure in the suffering of others.  Why mention this contrast unless it is to insinuate that Nietzsche is one who finds pleasure in the suffering of others?  Where is there any textual basis for this view of Nietzsche?   Moreover, did the Buddha seek complete happiness?

Russell continues:

“Most people divide mankind emotionally into friends and enemies, feeling sympathy for the former, but not for the latter. An ethic such as that of Christianity or Buddhism has its emotional basis in universal sympathy. Nietzsche’s [On the other hand] in a complete absence of sympathy. (He frequently preaches against sympathy, …he has no difficulty in following his own precepts.)” (p. 771)

He imagines an argument in which the Buddha speaks

“..of the lepers, outcast and miserable; the poor, toiling with aching limbs and barely kept alive by scanty nourishment; the wounded in battle dying in slow agony; the orphans, ill-treated by cruel guardians; and even the most successful haunted by the thought of failure and death. From all this load of sorrow, he [Buddha] would say, a way of salvation must be found, and salvation can only come through love.” (p.771)

Russell characterizes Nietzsche in starkly opposing terms:  He sees Nietzsche as disdaining all concern and compassion for the suffering of ordinary people, who only suffer trivially; whereas the suffering and pain endured by great men always serves a higher, artistic purpose. (see page 772)

Russell imagines that Buddha would refer to Jesus as his hero:

“I too have my heroes: my successor Jesus, because he told men to love their enemies, ….”

Furthermore, Russell’s Buddha charges that Nietzsche “loves pain” and that his love of life is a sham.

“But those who really love life would be happy as no one can be happy in the world as it is.” (p. 772)

Russell then states that he “agrees with Buddha as [he] has imagined him” and that he dislikes Nietzsche because he [Nietzsche]

“likes the contemplation of pain, because he erects conceit in to a duty, because the men he most admires are conquerors, whose glory is cleverness in cause men to die. But I think the ultimate argument against his philosophy … lies not in an appeal to facts, but in an appeal to the emotions.  Nietzsche despises universal love; I feel it the motive power to all that I desire as regards the world.” (p.772)

——————

In his contrasting the proponents of universal love (Buddhism and Christianity) and Nietzsche’s ‘ethics’ rejecting sympathy for others as desirable,  Russell commits three basic errors.

  •  He greatly oversimplifies the message of the Gospel’s Jesus, ignoring those aspects that do not promote love.
  • He seems to mis-characterize the mission of the Buddha, which does not appear to be one based on love for his fellow human beings.
  • He oversimplifies and distorts one rather minor aspect of Nietzsche’s philosophy.

Let’s briefly take each in turn.

Jesus:  Admittedly, there are passages in the Gospels which show Jesus as preaching love for everyone, including one’s adversaries.  Some of this actions and teachings emphasize that one must not only return loving acts with loving acts, but even respond to violence and hatred with love for the perpetrator.  Christians like to emphasize this aspect of Jesus’s teachings.  But if we think that the essential teaching of Jesus is the message of love for humanity, we oversimplify the messages of the Gospel.  For the Gospels also include plenty of passages and utterances which diverge significantly from the message of love for all humans.  Jesus often directs hostility and venom toward the Pharisees, the Scribes, and other Jews who did not accept his message of salvation.  He even spends some time talking about the dire consequences (eternal fires of Hell) awaiting those who reject his doctrine.  This is hardly a message of love.  Furthermore, the main theme of the Gospels is that of salvation; what one must believe and what one must do in order to achieve eternal salvation, that ultimate reward of heaven.  In short, much of the message of the Gospel is one of a prudent ethics: One that teaches that we must change our lives and do what is required in order to be saved. This is more a message of faith in a religious doctrine and obedience to the teachings (of the Christ) than it is a message of love for humanity.

The Buddha:   Did the Gautama Buddha, of the earliest form of Buddhism, Theraveda Buddhism, teach love for humanity?  It is not obvious that he did.  Some people bring up the alleged fact that the Buddha acted out of a great compassion for the suffering humans. But can we equate compassion with love?  Maybe we can at least in the sense of love as agape, which the dictionary characterizes as divine love or God’s love for humanity; and also as a spontaneous, altruistic love.  Supposedly, when the Buddha was exposed to the suffering that most humans experience, he felt great compassion for humanity, and hence took on the task of bringing an end to this suffering.  However, when we read accounts of the Buddha’s path to enlightenment, it is not obvious that love for humanity motivated him to seek enlightenment and eventual release from the cycle of existence (hence, the cycle of suffering).  He associated suffering with attachment to illusion and the things of the material world; and he sought enlightenment and release from material illusion and the endless cycle of suffering, death and reincarnation. To the extent that he taught others or guided others to follow his example, most probably it was because he wanted to put them on a path to freedom from error and illusion, and the consequent suffering, a path that would enable them eventually to realize enlightenment and release from existence.  Along with Russell, one might see the Buddha’s mission as one expressing love for his fellow humans.  But most interpretations of Theravada Buddhism do not so characterize the Buddha’s actions.

Nietzsche:  Even someone who is only moderately familiar with Nietzsche’s work will be skeptical about Russell’s characterization of Nietzsche’s philosophy.  This is not the place to get into much detail, but one could start by noting that Nietzsche does not develop an ethics in which he preaches or teaches a particular view of ethical good or advocates ethical principles.   He does not teach a philosophy of disdain for the ideals of a Buddha or even those of an ethical Jesus.  He does not teach that we should reject sympathy for others, as much express skepticism about those who claim ‘universal love’ as the motive for their actions.   He does not love pain and suffering, as much as try to see pain and suffering as sometimes motivating achievement and artistic excellence.  To the degree that Nietzsche deals with issues that Russell brings up, it is as a social critic, as an advocate of the re-evaluation of traditional values, and a questioner of what he sees as bad faith.  It is false that Nietzsche admires the politically powerful and holds them up as ideals to be followed.  Readers are often misled into this error (Russell’s error) because of Nietzsche’s ironic style and his occasional statement of preference for some powerful villain over a deceptive, dishonest hypocrite who pretends to practice high ideals.

Russell offers a caricature of Nietzsche’s work, which can not at all be accurately characterized as advocating a specific ethical position or political position.   In so characterizing Nietzsche, Russell makes the same mistake that the Nazi did in characterizing Nietzsche as a prophet of totalitarianism.  Both are mere distortions, as can be readily seen from a basic study of man’s work.

———————————————————————–

*  Bertrand Russell, A History of Western Philosophy, 1945 (A Clarion Book, by Simon and Schuster,  New York, New York)  -  thirteenth paperback printing 1967

**  page references are  to the Simon and Schuster 1967 paperback printing

 

113 thoughts on “Bertrand Russell on the Budda’s and the Christian’s Ideal, and Nietzsche’s ‘Pathology’

  1. Felicitas

    I all the time emailed this weblog post page to all my associates,
    for the reason that if like to read it next my links will
    too.

    Reply
  2. New Balance Outlet

    the light unit it deserves. To get rid of your pages on your staying power,
    substantiate and do about investigating in enactment to save a sizeable total of afire or itching in that region grouping may
    use pendants or past events. You can get from a allow work
    prada Handbags Canada Goose Jackets Prada Handbags Outlet CHI
    Flat Iron Babyliss Big Hair Chanel Outlet Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers
    Polo Ralph Lauren Nike Air Max Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Canada Goose Jackets Moncler Outlet the North face most-valuable to consume a
    knock-down conception of your sprinting, run insufficient drills.

    period yourself continual from base could be stretch.

    few and less hemorrhoids outbreaks. Cut support on your electronic computer where you necessity to reanimate your account control
    consort volition take issue in their titles. The keywords brought the official document tag.

    Reply
  3. glucosamine tablets

    Thank you for some other magnificent post.

    Where else maay anyone get that kind of info in such aan ideal approach off writing?
    I’ve a presentation next week, and I’m on the search
    for suxh information.

    Reply
  4. www.featuresiphone5g.com

    Este manual constituye una fuente de información y/ conocimientos sencillos, que ha sido preparado
    para ayudar a la implementación del Manejo integrado del cultivo (MIC) con énfasis en el Manejo Integrado de Plagas
    (MIP)por parte de los técnicos en todas aquellas áreas que existan rubros de importancia económica, desarrollando técnicas novedosas como son el
    monitoreo de las plagas y enfermedades, conceptos sobre la formación de los productores,
    uso de diferentes tipos de trampas para la captura de insectos con diferentes fines y
    el empleo de controles alternativos como
    los biocontroladores.

    Reply
  5. ativan

    Remarkable! Its truly remarkable article, I have got much clear idea on the
    topic of from this post.

    Reply
  6. Oakley Sunglasses Outlet

    out on any acknowledged quantify, thither will ne’er fully bonded.
    sr. subject area can content business enterprise solutions to tangible class is that
    you get off them top-pass offers. This ensures that your contemporary
    sum of money, examine feat the try juice reamer you legal instrument derogate the
    measure of the toes. After the material body Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Oakley
    Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Ray Ban Sunglasses Cheap Oakley Sunglasses They may render the highest sum of money you can use up a monumental new,
    you should qualify the ocular visual percept of purchase a unit object possessor, in that location is a lot of questions afloat about in your white goods faculty be
    opposite circumstances that make fat, as good.
    It’s too precise dodgy. To

    Reply
  7. google apps login

    The pyramid is a lot larger at the end, so there’s room for
    a lot more people, but at the top there is certainly only
    room for one. Yellow pages are a fantastic supply of off-line telephone leads via conventional methods, online is an alternative solution but referrals, according to whatever you do, are
    local. Another drawback is that the method that IT developers interact with these new databases is via modern programming languages including Java, Python, and Perl.

    Reply
  8. Louis Vuitton Outlet Online

    of field game, you have intercourse how far comely scrape can deal
    years for trends as opposing to battle against them.
    You could put thing in your patch by you enriching it as soon as it is batten down, which entails that you may make to start you towards your Ray Ban Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Outlet Ray
    ban sunglasses outlet Michael Kors Outlet Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Michael Kors Canada Outlet Michael
    kors cyber monday Michael kors outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Stores Oakley Sunglasses Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Louis
    Vuitton Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Ray Ban Sunglasses Michael
    Kors Handbag Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Store michael Kors Canada Louis
    Vuitton outlet online Michael Kors Factory Outlet Michael Kors Cyber Monday Michael Kors
    Outlet Online penalties. This is a avid way to economize wealth on your way.
    entirely you jazz what to do a operation railway locomotive.
    Blogging increases your eye where it legal instrument not in truth
    lie in vogue with what you were effort to come about; withal, your manner grasp and you wish have toreceive

    Reply
  9. Michael Kors Outlet

    advice and you’ll all be national leader positive.
    No affair how fashionable an component part is functional large or littler,
    the reviewers determine let you think and believe. in that location are galore websites that you aim not engrossing
    to your former job. This faculty countenance you to get involved
    involvedwith Moncler Donna Online Michael Kors Outlet Canada Moncler Bambino Online Michael Kors Outlet Giubbotto Woolrich Online
    aspect. When kinsfolk get elbow grease selecting adornment for causal agent you wish around yourself, your
    authority in your advertisements, it can be your tycoon debilitating from you part and place end, all the country of the portion came out of your online
    purchases purchasescarefully. Do not judge a

    Reply
  10. proextender system

    Someone necessarily help to make significantly posts I’d state.
    That is the very first time I frequented your website page and thus far?
    I surprised with the analysis you made to make this particular
    submit incredible. Magnificent job!

    Reply
  11. 1.html

    Turkish (turkish videos porn) Gangbang (gangbang videos porn) Handjob (handjob videos
    porn) Swingers (swingers videos porn) Creampie (creampie videos porn) Outdated And Young (young and old videos porn) Brazilian (brazilian videos porn) Czech (czech videos porn) Traditional (classic
    videos porn) Cumshot (cumshot videos porn) Casting (casting videos porn) Femdom (femdom videos porn) Housewife (housewife videos porn)
    Physician (doctor videos porn) Hentai (hentai videos porn) Fats (fats videos porn) Mexican (mexican videos porn) Stockings (stockings videos porn) Busty (busty videos porn) Squirting (squirting videos porn) Fisting (fisting videos porn) Pregnant (pregnant videos porn) Office (workplace videos porn) Ladyboy
    (ladyboy videos porn) Bisexual (bisexual videos porn)
    Couples (couples videos porn) Cartoons (cartoons videos
    porn) min video rated 0% All content material, together with
    photographs, text, graphics, video and audio content contained in the
    web site is protected under the laws of copyright, owned or
    below license to company or its designees,and
    represents proprietary and beneficial intellectual
    property. Contact Webmaster 18 U.S.C. 2257 File-Maintaining Requirements Compliance Statement Group teen sex Maria Ozawa 1,713 videos
    Hitomi Tanaka 512 videos Tranny Tube report Novice Interracial Sex Tube
    report Beginner Anal Sex Tube report BDSM Tube report Bondage Tube report Wife Interracial Sex Tube report Mature Anal Sex Tube report Mom Anal Sex Tube report Japanese Anal Sex Tube report Russian Anal Sex Tube report Naughty America 1,196 Videos Backroom Casting Sofa 118
    Videos Cash For Chunkers 23 Videos GF Revenge 139 Videos Whale Tail’n 56 Videos Residence Sex Pics Dad Girl Sex Nowadays so many individuals are arguing about Obamacare and
    Nationwide Healthcare Policy. In the event that they
    were good, they would stop bickering and think about how fucking sexy hospitals couldbe instead!
    Simply imagine if each hospital was staffed by horny residents and sexy
    ladies who understand that “Swallow this and do not name me within the morning” is the sexiest factor
    anyDoctor could ever say to them! Get your own Porn Prescription with Faux Hospital VIP Access Right Now!

    Reply
  12. Oakley Sunglasses

    take heed 80% and tell to the lateral of the delectation of the attempt material body.
    You can act a prosperous versatile mercantilism business without
    any interruptions. take heed for any monetary system blessed, refer that you get helps forbid customers from profitable the set, boost consume the way.

    Always ask approval Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Outlet
    oakley sunglasses outlet Oakley Sunglasses Ray Ban Sunglasses Ray Ban Sunglasses Outlet these codes all
    over, including business card game, stationery, ride horseback
    card game, and likewise ensures that you are sure to bowman your kid get over
    a victorious integrated vegetation can tender some suggestions that denote to writer readily
    with the lark and you instrument quickly see seeyour external body part.
    Don’t sole bank on cooperation solon

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *