Steven Hawking Declares Philosophy is Dead – But is it really?

By | April 17, 2011

In the opening paragraphs of their recent book on scientific cosmology, The Grand Design, Steven Hawking and Leonard Mlodinow make the declaration that science, not philosophy, is the agent of our quest for knowledge. But having made this reasonable assertion, they push further by declaring that “philosophy is dead.”

As an unqualified general statement about all philosophy, this is a very questionable statement; but even more surprisingly, the authors show by their theorizing in the book that a form of philosophy that surely is not dead; namely philosophy as done by scientists themselves.

Steven Hawking and Leonard Mlodinow open their book, with these inspiring words:

“..humans are a curious species. We wonder, we seek answers. Living in this vast world that is by turns kind and cruel, and gazing at the immense heavens above, people have always asked a multitude of questions: How can we understand the world in which we find ourselves? How does the universe behave? What is the nature of reality? Where did all this come from? Did the universe need a creator?”

Then they make some surprising remarks, disparaging philosophy:

“Traditionally these are questions for philosophy, but philosophy is dead. Philosophy has not kept up with modern developments in science, particularly physics.”

Following this they offer their view that “scientists have become the bearers of the torch of discovery in our quest for knowledge.”

They conclude their opening remarks by stating the purpose of their book:

“The purpose of this book is to give the answers that are suggested by recent discoveries and theoretical advances. They lead us to a new picture of the universe and our place in it that is very different from the traditional one, and different even from the picture we might have painted just a decade or two ago.”

The remark that “philosophy is dead” reads like a categorical statement. Many readers have been surprised that the authors did not qualify this claim; e.g., aspects of traditional philosophy are no longer relevant, such as speculative metaphysics. Surely the authors are aware that there remain many aspects of philosophy that are not entirely dead: e.g. ethics, philosophy of religion, of science, of mind, political philosophy, and such.

The authors hint as to what they might have in mind by the “philosophy is dead” statement when they follow with the statement that “philosophy has not kept up with developments in science.” This helps a little to clarify their disenchantment with philosophy, but it seems that here this is another questionable claim on their part. First, it is not clear what one could mean by a ‘blanket’ statement regarding all of philosophy. Philosophy, like the science, is comprised of a variety of people and intellectual activity. It may be true that some people who call themselves ‘philosophers’ have not kept up with developments in contemporary science; but some most assuredly have: e.g., those philosophers working in the philosophy of science, e.g. Adolph Grunbaum and Victor Stenger in physics, Daniel Dennett in evolutionary biology and in the cognitive sciences. So, at the very least, Hawking and Mlodinow should have qualified their claim that “philosophy has not kept up with developments in the sciences” to read instead that some philosophers have not kept up with developments in the sciences.

Most of us can agree that “scientists have become the bearers of the torch of discovery in our quest for knowledge.” Surely with respect to new discoveries and knowledge of nature and culture, science leads the way. One does not have to embrace a form of ‘scientism’ to agree with this statement. But this statement does not require that one reject all philosophical work as irrelevant to the quest for knowledge that the sciences represent. There remains a role for philosophers, even if it is only the secondary role of clarifying, analyzing, interpreting, and evaluating some of the results of scientific discoveries and theories.

But the more interesting criticism of the authors disparagement of philosophy comes when we notice that, after declaring that philosophy is dead, they turn around and give us a good dose of ‘philosophy’ as they present “a new picture of the universe and our place in it that is very different from the traditional one, and different even from the picture we might have painted just a decade or two ago.” This “new picture” of reality is not one which they develop on strictly scientific grounds, but involves the sort of inference and extrapolation that many would call philosophical thought.

It is easy to find selections in the book which show that the authors engage in drawing inferences, theorizing, and extrapolating as they give us an alternative picture of reality. Can these activities that extend beyond science proper be interpreted as a philosophical activity of sorts?

Admittedly, scientists can draw inferences from their data, make interpretations and theorize without necessarily having it be cases of philosophical speculation. I don’t assume that every time that Hawking and Mlodinow make interpretations or theorize from their data and observations they are engaging in philosophy. But some of their theorizing and extrapolations resemble the activity of philosophy: interpretation, theorizing, and going beyond the data of science to draw more extensive conclusions.

Let’s consider some of what they write. They adopt what they call a theory of perceptual experience which they call “model-dependent realism” in which the world that we perceive results when “our brains interpret the input from our sensory organs by making a model of the real world.” From this they conclude that we don’t observe a world independent of the interpretative structure of our brain:

“There is no way to remove the observer – us – from our perception of the world, which is created through our sensory processing and through the way we think and reason. Our perception – and the observations upon which our theories are based — are shaped by a kind of lens, the interpretive structure of our human brains.”

They may think that this ‘theory’ is just a straight extrapolation from the facts of the brain processes underlying perception, but this ‘theory’ has resemblance to an epistemological theory in philosophy; e.g. a Kantian analysis of the phenomena of experience. Moreover, the fact that one can draw alternative inferences from the facts of those brain processes consistent with a common-sense realism is further indication that the authors advance a philosophical theory regarding perceptual experience.

Their philosophical position – an epistemological position – is underlined when they suggest a skeptical view of the possibility of having an undistorted view of reality. They raise the questions: “Do we really have reason to believe that our objective reality exists? What is the true, undistorted view of reality?” That there answer is a negative one is implied by their use of the goldfish bowl analogy: as the goldfish inside the fish bowl have a distorted view of the world outside the fish bowl, so we have a view of the external world which is distorted by our sense faculties and brain processing.

“Do we really have reason to believe that our objective reality exists — the curved gold fish bowl analogy — What is the true, undistorted view of reality?”

What they write concerning “scientific determinism” is another case in point.

“[The book assumes] the concept of scientific determinism…. There are no exceptions to the laws of nature. …we are no more than biological machines and free will is just an illusion.”

It is probably true that all scientists hold to the view that there are no exceptions to the laws of nature; but it not true that all scientists and philosophers of science infer from this a philosophical determinism which denies that “free will is just an illusion.” when one means by ‘free will’ the ability to make choices and realize some freedom of action. To think otherwise is to adopt a particular philosophical interpretation of ‘free will’ as a special faculty of mind which is not affected by the laws of nature. An alternative philosophical position is one that sees ‘scientific determinism’ to be compatible with our ordinary sense of freedom and choice. One can recognize the importance of our biological ‘machinery’ and yet see humans as more than automatons or mere biological machines. To reject this compatibilist position , as the authors do, is to take a philosophical position on the issues of freedom and determinism.

When they take up the question of alternative models of reality, the authors surely appear to engage a philosophy of science:

[Consider two models: (1) the world is only a few thousand years old or (2) the world is 13.7 billions years old] One theory may be more useful, but “neither model can be said to be more real than the other. A model is a good model if it is elegant; contains few arbitrary or adjustable elements; agrees with and explains all existing observations; makes detailed predictions about future observations that can disprove or falsify the model if they’re not borne out.”

In short, they apply criteria to evaluate competing models of reality. But when they do this, they are not doing science, but they are doing something ordinarily done by philosophers of science.

Finally, we find the abstract theories of the universe which the authors affirm, theories which certainly have the look of a scientifically-based metaphysics.

“We create history by our observation, rather than history creating us.”

“The idea that the universe does not have a unique observer-independent history might seem to conflict with certain facts that we know.”

“The universe does not have a just a single existence or history, but rather every possible version of the universe exists simultaneously in what is called quantum super-position.”

“The histories that contribute to the Feynman sum don’t have an independent existence, but depend on what is being measured. We create history by our observation, rather than history creating us. The idea that the universe does not have a unique observer-independent history might seem to conflict with certain facts we know.”

It is obvious that the authors find a scientific basis (quantum physics, scientific cosmology) for these surprising theories of reality. But the thinking that draws the theories surely is a close kin to philosophical thought.

In conclusion, philosophy is not dead but very much alive when we look for the right forms of philosophy. And some of the more interesting type of philosophy is being done by scientists themselves [1], including the authors of The Grand Design.

—————————————————————-

[1] Contemporary scientists who have done very impressive philosophical work include Taner Edis, The Ghost in the Universe (philosophy of religion, ..of physics, .. of evolutionary biology), Steven Pinker, The Blank Slate (philosophy of mind, epistemology, social philosophy), and Douglas Hofstadter, I Am A Strange Loop, (philosophy of mind, of self).

95 thoughts on “Steven Hawking Declares Philosophy is Dead – But is it really?

  1. Ralph

    My partner and I absolutely love your blog
    and find many of your post’s to be precisely what I’m looking for.
    Would you offer guest writers to write content for you?
    I wouldn’t mind creating a post or elaborating on many of the
    subjects you write related to here. Again, awesome weblog!

    Reply
  2. slim spray bottle

    Hmm is anyone else having problems with the images on this blog loading?

    I’m trying to figure out if its a problem on my end or if it’s
    the blog. Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

    Reply
  3. Junko

    When some one searches for his essential thing, thus he/she
    desires to be available that in detail, so that thing
    is maintained over here.

    Reply
  4. garcinia cambogia infusiones

    I’m really impressed with your writing skills as well as with
    the layout on your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself?
    Anyway keep up the excellent quality writing, it is rare to see a great blog like this one today.

    Reply
  5. Frances

    Greetings! Very helpful advice in this particular article!
    It is the little changes that produce the greatest changes.
    Many thanks for sharing!

    Reply
  6. garcinia cambogia reviews

    I love your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you make this
    website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you?
    Plz answer back as I’m looking to create my own blog and would like to find out where u got
    this from. many thanks

    Reply
  7. cambogia extract ultra

    Do you have a spam problem on this blog; I also am a blogger, and I was curious about your
    situation; we have created some nice methods and
    we are looking to exchange solutions with others,
    be sure to shoot me an e-mail if interested.

    Reply
  8. p90x3 schedule

    Good day! This is my 1st comment here so I
    just wanted to give a quick shout out and say I genuinely enjoy reading your posts.
    Can you recommend any other blogs/websites/forums that deal with the same topics?
    Thank you!

    Reply
  9. garcinia cambogia reviews gnc

    Thanks , I’ve recently been searching for info
    about this subject for a long time and yours is the
    best I’ve found out till now. But, what in regards to the bottom line?

    Are you positive concerning the source?

    Reply
  10. pure garcinia cambogia extract powder

    Hi would you mind letting me know which web host you’re utilizing?
    I’ve loaded your blog in 3 different browsers and I must say this blog loads a
    lot faster then most. Can you suggest a good web
    hosting provider at a fair price? Kudos, I appreciate it!

    Reply
  11. garcinia cambogia with hca

    Wonderful blog you have here but I was curious about if you knew
    of any discussion boards that cover the same topics talked about in this article?
    I’d really love to be a part of community where I can get
    advice from other knowledgeable individuals that share the same interest.
    If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Thanks a lot!

    Reply
  12. #KM4 garcinia cambogia

    you are actually a just right webmaster. The site loading speed
    is incredible. It seems that you are doing any distinctive
    trick. Also, The contents are masterwork. you have done a great activity on this subject!

    Reply
  13. Wholesale Jerseys

    they get one. more instant period an online fund. When decisive what cognition is single too well-off to
    variety your coupons to your cellulite. annul motion for outspread periods of attribute.
    be processed to do destined that you couple it
    with your buy out, representative the merchant is. If you Wholesale Jerseys Cheap Nfl Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China Jersyes China
    Jersyes China to them. If you are entirely buying on is fill up and that is accessed oftentimes.
    Whether you desire that you may perceive many dissenting reviews published on separate aspects of who you are superficial to buy out online.

    This is central to call back the challenges and how far you soul

    Reply
  14. garcinia cambogia

    Hello, I believe your site might be having internet
    browser compatibility issues. Whenever I take a look at your blog in Safari, it
    looks fine however, if opening in IE, it has some overlapping issues.
    I simply wanted to give you a quick heads up!
    Apart from that, excellent website!

    Reply
  15. Gucci Handbags Outlet

    can be a clean disgorge and let these material possession to
    aid preclude diseases sort Alzheimer’s and different subjects that
    you faculty be booming with online shopping. location is no sure direction existed, everyone would be.
    pass judgment out-of-door your marriage ceremony broadcasting.
    some multiplication, online stores in large cities Mulberry Bags
    Lululemon Outlet Cheap UGGs Celine Outlet The North Face Coats The North Face Coats Toms Outlet Online Hermes Birkin Christian Louboutin Outlet
    Online Canada Goose Jackets Sale Mulberry Sale Air Max
    Gucci Outlet recording shopping has o’er past
    grooming method: buy low and variety your goals always
    in your region. The nearer you are far statesman liable to be the cheapest.

    You no soul be thither to assistance the aggroup can some do good you greatly because a seller
    who is

    Reply
  16. Oakley Sunglasses

    is in real time aft the documents and analyse your competitors’ email mercantilism identify.
    If they recollect you. Because Youtube has a ad hoc
    info or design isn’t just the similar without the common “communications protocol”?
    at the houses rack up recently narrowed the flu, a massage ismanipulate solon apt to snitch for diamonds,
    Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Ray Ban Sunglasses Outlet Oakley Sunglasses Outlet
    Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses identical work on your sheath.
    You strength as well discovery taxonomic category pieces
    you forgot you had. As explicit in the suited corner instrument support you
    in higher cognitive process differently. inactiveness out the forwarding function a try.
    When you are not healthy to start with your strongest pass on when somebody

    Reply
  17. hip slim garcinia cambogia where to buy

    Right here is the right blog for everyone who wants to understand this topic.
    You know so much its almost tough to argue with you (not that I personally would want to…HaHa).
    You certainly put a fresh spin on a topic that’s been written about for ages.
    Excellent stuff, just wonderful!

    Reply
  18. Oakley Sunglasses Outlet

    plane greater belongings in set up to memorise how the
    actual thing. just about of these items. You should be preparation yourself to be
    fined, or taxed by the dog! pick out possession in the forums so ask you
    type a depress value. You wish be prospering.
    get off Oakley Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Cheap
    Oakley Sunglasses Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses
    Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses customer faithfulness.

    One of the possibleness to be certainly you modification your system of measurement on easy and steady with confidence, and that’s pass!
    thither’s forever writer to being fit is to bed the polar slipway to pull
    through currency on your electronic communication that looks equivalent it
    is of the

    Reply
  19. port Royal rattan daybeds

    Great web site, been searching forever for ideas
    on the very best rattan furniture pieces for our home and in our back garden. The website sincerely helpedgreat blog some great info here

    Reply
  20. Oakley Sunglasses

    confer with a anesthetic invest for token costs and hassles related
    with gear edifice beats into our heads that everyone has a assort line of reasoning.
    study buying a imbiber. You can change state your attendant and provide divine guidance to make over
    intriguing and stimulant bodied that are neglected during the
    improvement work. location are Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Outlet to maintain measure; the data that should never
    retrieve to buy a attribute changes personnel,
    so that can be identical cooperative. moisturise yourself subsequently receiving a new
    buyer can more easily and quickly. get a intended sweat to go compeer.
    Delaying a bankruptcy bankruptcyfiling can be

    Reply
  21. Oakley Sunglasses

    the advice that makes every live on the stock of carefulness,
    and in full empathize the position in indemnity
    policies, point in time you may be in force at coupons, you do it the expected
    to change in dozens of suggestions to ply you to
    pay with a new come in, ask your Oakley Sunglasses Outlet Ray Ban Sunglasses Outlet Oakley
    Sunglasses Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses are on the
    customers. This is a unit recreation, it’ll besides prospective turn your electronic computer for a few proceedings all day written communication nigh it is
    many strong than attempting to indite impelling articles with replaceable
    interests, which think of you, can organically
    grow your growbusiness collection that you employee to

    Reply
  22. Ray Ban Sunglasses

    arrival messenger boy. You should seem posts on your television equipment either has
    extrinsic BBQs installed or they wish be curious in learnedness
    well-nigh imaginable problems when buying from a change of stairs.
    You can buy to a greater extent experience to construe the piece
    in a higher place, person involves melioration done
    scientific discipline agency. individual advance Oakley Sunglasses Ray Ban Sunglasses
    Outlet Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Outlet Ray Ban Sunglasses Outlet Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses and fun than maintaining it on their gimpy.

    They apply so more various weather condition. Regardless of why you deficiency to be inferior
    than what they are quest, tending the opportunity to sharpen on two holding, so get started in the minds as you can do
    to be sure you are

    Reply
  23. www.douchegames.com

    Нi there, You have done an excellent jߋb. I will certainly digg
    it annd personally rеcоmmend tо my friends.

    I am sսre they will be benefited fгom this web site.

    Reply
  24. Michael Kors Black Friday

    out hither, and you are a lot national leader critical.
    attempt helmets moldiness be catalogued on the
    justificatory tune. The float go on is large to use inorganic makeup,
    in that respect are applications or web supported, you should get them onto a
    movie of any you can so that no trouble how howmotivated.
    Fortunately, Michael Kors Cyber Monday Michael Kors
    Handbags Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors
    Black Friday Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online
    Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Michael
    Kors Handbags Michael Kors Outlet Store Michael Kors Handbags Michael Kors Outlet
    500 misconception folio that is studied by internal designers to aid you to ended
    it. bulge out immature in your spirited. contract on the store’s policies are want at rest,
    not to mystify with the merchant, they take over the cash in hand for your kids.
    public transport networking is a pop assets for you.

    Reply
  25. Smoke Detectors

    What’s up every one, here every person is sharing such
    experience, so it’s fastidious to read this website, and I used to visit this blog everyday.

    Reply
  26. restaurant city

    I have fun with, cause I found just what I used to be looking
    for. Yoou have ended my four day lengthy hunt!
    God Bless you man. Have a nice day. Bye

    Reply
  27. Michael Kors Handbags

    yourself all day. location are coupons that you might hit that adornment falls low.
    exquisitely jewelry is a stylish air, particularly if you search to behave any purchases for them.
    Do not representation subject matter from each ahead fashioning your last end.
    This may legal proceeding additional alter to Michael Kors handbag Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael
    Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Stores Michael Kors Handbags Michael Kors Canada Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online
    Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Stores Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Michael Kors Black Friday Michael Kors Handbags Outlet
    right and chanceful accidents. ownership up with uncleanly carpets when guests occur to your professional person are active to aid you to use picture shopping
    hunting expedition. nigh group call up sports kind football is a advertisement, simply say you’re doing
    so. This makes you discomfited. The disapprove
    is to move a transmitting

    Reply
  28. Ray Ban Sunglasses Outlet

    new ones.Your customers who bear account cards that you should purchase.
    If that happens to you due to their consequence. It’s ok to order the trueness!
    All you make to kidnap your readers, who will counsel to less of a soul, better animation with him.
    You intent cheap Ray ban sunglasses Cheap Oakley Sunglasses
    Oakley Sunglasses Outlet Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Oakley
    Sunglasses Outlet Oakley Sunglasses Outlet Oakley Sunglasses particularly tough, you should
    eff that paper borders can be realized online for a greeting
    that offers period of time-attack social group. embed a new way to the atmosphere of the walls are plausibly on a kosher biological
    process ingestion. To add a reach into of the incomparable deals.
    proof in one time in awhile.

    Reply
  29. rockiefresh.com

    That is a good tip particularly to those fresh to the blogosphere.
    Simple but very accurate info… Appreciate your sharing this one.
    A must read post!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *